David Miliband to make statement on Binyam Mohamed 'torture cover up'

David Miliband will make a statement to the House of Commons today on the alleged cover-up of the torture of Binyam Mohamed, a former British resident being held at Guantanamo Bay.
The Foreign Secretary faces tough questioning from MPs on the diplomatic pressure applied by both President Bush and President Obama's Administrations for Britain to keep secret Mr Mohamed's alleged mistreatment in secret US jails in Pakistan, Afghanistan and Morocco.
He is also likely to be quizzed on how far MI6 agents were complicit in the alleged torture. Mr Mohamed claims that British spies interviewed him during the time he alleges he was having his chest and penis cut with a scalpel and stinging liquid poured into the wounds, and that they passed on detailed personal information about him to his torturers.
Mr Miliband has been forced to make the statement after two British judges released a damning ruling on Mr Mohamed's case yesterday. The judges complained that they could not release details of Mr Mohamed's alleged mistreatment and Britain's role in it, even though it was in the interests of justice, because America had threatened to withdraw intelligence co-operation from Britain and this could put British lives at risk.
Related Links
Judges accuse US over torture evidence
Obama faces rough ride as shine tarnishes
US company chiefs face salary caps as penance
"It was and remains (so far as we are aware) the judgment of the Foreign Secretary that the United States Government might carry out that threat and this would seriously prejudice the national security of the United Kingdom," the judges wrote.
Lord Justice Thomas and Mr Justice Lloyd Jones added that the information they wanted to release - about 25 lines of text about Mr Mohamed's case, taken from official documents from American intelligence agencies - posed no threat to British or US security, but was potentially "embarrassing" as it did add to up to "an arguable case of torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment", in contravention of national and international law.
So far Mr Miliband has denied that the US issued any threat, but he has admitted that America said that publishing the information would badly damage its relations with Britain. "There has been no threat from the United States to 'break off' intelligence co-operation," he told Channel 4 News last night.
"Intelligence co-operation depends on confidentiality. We share our secrets with other countries and they share their secrets with us. The founding principle for us and for them is that we can trust the confidentiality of that relationship.
"In this case, the United States made it clear, in documents that have been published, that there would inevitably be serious and lasting harm if that fundamental principle was breached."
He later told BBC Newsnight: "If I authorise the sharing of information with another country I don't want them (the judges) to jeopardise our intelligence service by releasing that information against our will."
The Conservatives, the Liberal Democrats, human rights experts, and lawyers and family of Mr Mohamed have all decried this, claiming that allegations of torture were too serious ever to be suppressed or condoned.
"No British government should participate in or condone torture under any circumstances," said William Hague, the Shadow Foreign Secretary. “We hope the new US administration will look again at this decision, particularly since the judge concluded that there were no security reasons for the material not to be made public.”
Mr Hague said he hoped that any British agent thought to have condoned or participated in torture would be prosecuted.
Nick Clegg, the leader of the Liberal Democrats, said that the case smacked of cover up.
"Torture is unacceptable under all circumstances, and that is what we should be concentrating on. There is no excuse not to make that information public," he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme.
Mr Mohamed's brother, Dr Benhur Mohamed, said that the decision to block the release of information about his brother's detention was "unacceptable". He added that he had written to Mr Miliband asking him to help his brother, but was bitterly disappointed to have received no reply.
"I was truly begging him to do something about Binyam, that was my plea, but I didn't hear anything," Dr Mohamed told BBC Radio 5 Live.
"I feel very sad, I feel betrayed. It's very cruel from a person who is elected by the people to protect humanity and freedom and the rule of law."
Dr Mohamed claimed that his brother, who is not currently accused of any crime after the US dropped charges that he was involved in an alleged dirty bomb plot, was a "quiet" and "helpful" person. "He is very supportive and very considerate. He is not the kind of person who would want to hurt anybody," he said.
Lt Colonel Yvonne Bradley, Mr Mohamed's US military lawyer, who visited him in Guantanamo Bay last week, said that America wanted to save face. "What the US is doing right now is not so much about national security or intelligence - it's about being embarrassed," she said.
Mr Miliband said: "We never condone or authorise the use of torture."
He said that the allegation that British agents may have been complicit in Mr Mohamed's alleged torture had been referred to the Attorney General, Baroness Scotland.